Apr. 21st, 2010

maggie2: (Default)

So today's not a very happy day for me in the fandom.   But I decided to cheer myself up by kvetching about what IDW is doing to the character they call Spike.  I want to rant and bash and rant and bash some more cause I just hate every idea they come up with over there.  I thought Lynch did OK -- he was off on Spike, but he had enough that was right that I could see why other people like his work.  But since then Willingham has taken the things that bugged me about Lynch's Spike and put them on steroids.  Willingham is the guy who had a public meltdown about Joss stepping on *his* authorial privilege, a rant a lot of folks on my flist had sympathy with.  I find it hard to get worked up about Willingham getting Jossed when Willingham can't be bothered to get to know the characters he's writing.  I mean, if he's going to invent a bunch of folks, why not give them their own names and write a comic about them?  Why pretend the story is related to AtS? 

The offense in question was linked to on Whedonesque and reads as follows:

"The spoiler for this is that Spike from the 'Angel' series has been wondering for some time why prophecy never works out for him, why he's never the good guy," the writer said. "He's been looking into who gets to write prophecy. Do you go to school? Do you get a certificate? Is there a board of prophets that licenses you to?"

Circumstances will soon present Spike with the opportunity to tip prophecies in his favor, according to Willingham.

"One, he comes into a bit of money, and two, he has access to tons and tons of out-of-work Hollywood lawyers, so he starts hiring them to write prophecies where he's the star," he explained.

No, see, this makes total sense because Spike fought Angel for the Shanshu in Destiny, cause, you know, he just wanted to have it.  It had *nothing* to do with them working out a century worth of issues.  It was cause Spike just wants center stage and will do anything to get it.   Spike's all about Spike and wanting to make sure the world's all about Spike too.

I know there are a bunch of people who are terrified about what Joss will end up doing to Spike.  But I don't think I could imagine a worse set of stories about Spike than the ones I've been hearing about over at IDW.   I'm a very bad person.  I want their sales to tank and then tank some more.  I'm all about the Schadenfreude when it comes to IDW.  Bad, bad, Maggie.

Meanwhile the burning question of the day: which is worse -- a Spike who screws a celebrity vampire with the intention of torturing her for information later; or this?  For me, it's this.  There's something about the way this completely misunderstands the character that drives me up a tree. 

maggie2: (Default)
It turns out that according to some people if you ever complain about how Spike is characterized it's because the only thing you want in this whole entire world is to see Spike and Buffy making with the smoochies. 

I shouldn't have to say this, but I will.  I love Spike because he's a damned Champion.   As a demon he wanted to be treated like a man.  When he failed he fought for a soul.  He came back to help expecting nothing in return.  He died because he felt it was his part to do.  He came back and took up the fight, notably not running back to Buffy for the smoochies.  He had the wisdom to see that there's a hole in the world.  The poetry to see how things work or don't work. 

He's not perfect (see, e.g. the Harmony hop), he works at being annoying, he's probably an alcoholic.  But he's not a self-serving, sex-crazed, thuggish moron. 

That is sufficient reason to be unhappy with Willingham.  What kool aid do you have to drink to read the present irritation with Willingham as nothing but a mad desire to see some smoochies?   Especially when that irritation is coming from someone who is *at best* ambivalent about wanting any Spuffy in the future.  I'm guessing it's some pretty damned powerful kool aid.


maggie2: (Default)

September 2010

    1 234
5 678 91011
12 131415 161718
19 2021 22 232425
26 272829 30  

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags